UK Court of Appeal grants leave to challenge Buffer Zones outside abortion clinics

politics
UK Court of Appeal grants leave to challenge Buffer Zones outside abortion clinics

The UK Court of Appeal in London has granted Leave to Alina Dulgheriu of the Be Here for Me Campaign , a group of Mothers who were helped by vigil members outside abortion clinics to challenge the legality of an order by Ealing Council in London banning a group of Pro Life Volunteers named the Good Counsel Network from standing outside a Marie Stopes abortion clinic on Mattock Lane . 
 
The Council had created a Public Space Protection Order (PSPO) normally used for anti social behaviour to crack down on the volunteers who had been operating outside the clinic for the past 23 years offering help and support to women in crisis pregnancy . Under the Councils Order any act of approval/disapproval with respect to issues related to abortion services by any means graphic, verbal or written , prayer or counselling is strictly prohibited . 

 
Last July , The High Court upheld the Councils order .  Although the High Court found that fundamental rights had been infringed through the implementation of the censorship zone, it ultimately decided to uphold the PSPO, and ordered Ms. Dulgheriu to pay Ealing Council’s legal costs . 
 
Ms Dulgheriu subsequently launched a crowdfunding campaign to pay her legal costs and appeal the high courts decision which raised over £50,000 in less than 3 months. In January , The Court of Appeal granted Leave to Ms Dulgheriu to challenge the High Court ruling . 
 
A recent review by the UK Government found that out of 363 hospitals and clinics in England and Wales that carried out abortions in 2017 , 36 clinics experienced anti abortion activities and the majority were passive in nature .
 
Rejecting calls to introduce Nationwide buffer zones , Britain's Home Secretary Sajid Javid said that protest-free areas around clinics in England and Wales "would not be a proportionate response" because cases of harassment were "not the norm" . He said laws already existed such as the Public Order Act 1986 to prevent harassment, adding - "In this country, it is a long-standing tradition that people are free to gather together and to demonstrate their views. "This is something to be rightly proud of" ..."Having considered the evidence of the review, I have therefore reached the conclusion that introducing national buffer zones would not be a proportionate response, considering the experiences of the majority of hospitals and clinics, and considering that the majority of activities are more passive in nature." 
 
 

Below Alina Dulgheriu with her daughter Sarah outside Court . 
 
 
 
Below: Pro Life Activists from the Good Counsel Network outside Abortion Clinic in Ealing
   

Related article

Harris flips out over Comments made by Pro Life Doctor

Harris flips out over Comments made by Pro Life Doctor

Videos
Minister for Health , Simon Harris has threatened hospitals that refuse to carry out abortions with the Direct Placement of HSE staff who will do it . Harris was
Ben Scallon talks to members of public about abortion

Ben Scallon talks to members of public about abortion

Ben Scallon of Conservative Comeback Ireland and the Irish Freedom Party talks to members of the public about the issue of abortion . https://www.facebook.com/IrishComeback/videos/vb.1929474170451782/1933075830091616/?type=2&theater
Video Clips - All Ireland Rally For Life Dublin

Video Clips - All Ireland Rally For Life Dublin

Random Video Clips from the All Ireland Rally for Life held on July 6 in Dublin City Centre . Includes clips of Youth Defence . Also caught on camera was
50,000 attend all Ireland Rally for Life

50,000 attend all Ireland Rally for Life

politics
Upwards of 50,000 people from around Ireland descended on Dublin City Centre on Saturday for the annual all Ireland Rally for Life . The Parade of colourful pro life

Also in politics

Trinity Professor slams Irish Times over extreme anti Brexit rhetoric

Trinity Professor slams Irish Times over extreme anti Brexit rhetoric

politics
The Former head of Social Policy at Trinity College Dublin Prof Anthony Coughlan has slammed Irish Times Columnist Fintan O'Toole and the Irish Times over its extreme anti English
Norway - Whale saves iphone from sea

Norway - Whale saves iphone from sea

Videos
A Beluga whale saves an iPhone from the sea in Norway http://www.thetricolour.com/videos/whale-saves-iphone.mp4
The rise of communism and end of freedom of expression in Ireland

The rise of communism and end of freedom of expression in Ireland

politics
On Saturday 10th of August , a twitter based group called #speakersunicorner run by artist Robert Bohan and LGBT activist Izzy kamikaze (also known as Izzy O'Rourke) held a protest
Student Guide to University

Student Guide to University

Videos
This video has over 14 million views ( 4 million within two months ) , It delves into the potential dangers of a hypersensitive culture bred by social media
Reply
#
Interesting Case to follow , Irish Courts will usually arrive at the same determinations as the UK Courts , Freedom of expression and assembly are fundamental rights in any democracy . I expect a similar challenge will be brought before the Irish Courts as a number of councils are planning to impose similar bans here. I mean if they get away with it , you can ban any form of protest . mad really stuff thats happening

loginsignup